Candidate Refutes Letter Writer

In last week’s paper, City Council candidate Robert Davis challenged my statement that the City can have a less expensive sewer plant in its current location without trouble from either the Coastal Commission or the Water Board. He used statements from the sewer plant manager as evidence. 

I fail to see conflicts between my statement and the plant manager’s comments.

1. I agree the current sewer plant does not meet standards and will need to be upgraded. I believe an upgrade has to be cheaper than a brand new plant 3 miles away requiring 2 new lift stations and 4 pipelines, increased operational costs, with additional public services moving onto the new site.

2. I did not address BOD or TSS, so I’m not sure how this relates other than identifying the standard the City must reach.

3. I agree the City is operating under a Time Schedule Order. The Order is moot if fulfilled. If the City meets the secondary standard when Cayucos goes offline in December, we’ve beaten the 2023 deadline.

4. Same as #2, I agree upgrading is necessary.

5. The Coastal Commission denied a permit for the specific project proposed in 2013. While environmental reasons played a role, so did the newly-elected leaders’ request for denial. With a Time Order in place, the denial kept the City/Cayucos from Water Board fines. Fines could have happened if the project was continued.

During public comment at the Hearing, I did state, “We ask for your denial.” 

In 2013, the public reasoned that if a new plant could be built in a safer location for only $10-$12 more a month, we were willing to do that. In 2020, the reality is the new site is neither environmentally safer nor only $10-$12 more a month. 

Not only is the estuary at risk, sewer bills have risen from $41.35/mo. to $108/mo. (excluding water bill), not a 25% increase but a 161% increase.

I agree, “Voters should look for truth behind every claim made by candidates for public office.”

Betty Winholtz
Candidate for Morro Bay City Council

You May Also Like…

Letters to The Editor 9-22-2022

Meteorologist or Religion In regards to Scott Presnal’s letter (Vol.4, Issue 17) in the most recent issue of Estero...

Salvation Over Fear

Politics should be taken out of the science of what was known as global warming, now climate change, without scarring...

Vote ‘No’ on Harbor Tax

When I first moved to Morro Bay in 1999 the Harbor Dept. was financially very well off.   Now they are saying they are...